Suing someone in B.C: from Claim to Trial

If you are suing someone (or are being sued) for the first time, you may have wondered how it all proceeds from claim to trial. We wanted to save you from unnecessary stress, so we put together a general explanation of the process.

Litigation is the process of bringing disputes to court to resolve them by either a judge or jury. However, keep in mind that in B.C. and Canada, more generally, litigation is not the only mechanism for resolving disputes between private parties.

There are alternatives to court, such as mediation, arbitration, and negotiation. But before we go deeper into the stages of the trial process, let us clarify the difference between civil and criminal trials.

The primary difference between the two is that a civil trial is between two private parties (including corporations, which are classified as private parties), while a criminal trial is between a private party and the Crown. The Crown has the power to take away a person’s liberty (in accordance with the Charter of Rights), which in turn means that different procedures and standards of proof are involved in criminal trials. This article will only focus on civil trials, where the penalties are primarily monetary damages.

Civil cases can be started in either the Civil Resolution Tribunal, Provincial Court (Small Claims), or the Supreme Court of British Columbia. Your choice of court may be dependent on the amount of damages you are seeking, the complexity of the case, and the cost. In this article, the discussion will focus on proceedings in the Supreme Court of British Columbia.

The BC Supreme Court Rules dictate the correct procedure to use to start a proceeding. Most cases start with a notice of civil claim, but some cases begin with documents called a petition or requisition. Some limited cases start with a petition or requisition, including those relating to an interest in land, the interpretation of a will, and legal disability, while all other cases start with a notice of civil claim. These documents, and the responses to these documents, are called pleadings.

For a notice of civil claim, the party who starts the proceeding is called the plaintiff, and the party who defends the proceeding is called the defendant. When the case begins with a petition, the party who starts the proceeding is called the petitioner, while the party who defends it is called the petition’s respondent. Please note that the above description corresponds to a basic lawsuit. More complex suits can occur between parties, for example, a counterclaim or a third-party claim.

1. The plaintiff starts the action by filing and serving a notice of civil claim. The general rule is that a plaintiff must serve a notice of civil claim on the defendant within 12 months of filing it in the court registry.
2. The defendant must then file and serve a response on the plaintiff within 21 days of being served with the notice of civil claim if they were served in Canada. The Supreme Court Civil Rules establish longer timeframes if the defendant was served in the United States or somewhere else.
3. The defendant may decide to file and serve a counterclaim on the plaintiff during the response period.
4. If the defendant files such a counterclaim, the plaintiff must file and serve a response to the counterclaim.
5. Either party may choose to resolve the dispute via fast-track litigation by filing and serving a notice of fast-track action on the other party (discussed below).
6. If neither party files and serves a notice of fast-track action, the proceeding will continue as a regular trial and the plaintiff and defendant will start the discovery process (discussed below).
7. Either party may request a Case Planning Conference (“CPC”) by filing a notice of the case planning conference. At a CPC, the parties come together with a judge to discuss how the case will proceed. The judge will make a case plan order, which may address things including dispute resolution options and dates for deadlines for the exchange of documents.
8. Both the plaintiff and defendant will prepare for the trial by setting the trial date, preparing their arguments, consulting any expert witnesses, and preparing their evidence.
9. The parties will attend the trial itself, and at the end, the judge will give a judgment and award any costs.

If necessary, either the plaintiff or defendant may apply for an appeal of the judgment.

This is a shorter, quicker, and more efficient form of litigation that can be used if the action was started by a notice of civil claim. The steps used in fast-track litigation are similar to those seen in traditional litigation. However, there are fewer procedural hurdles, because it is a process designed to save the parties time and money.

Fast-track litigation only applies to actions where the monetary damages being claimed are $100,000 or less, if the action needs no more than three days of trial, or if the parties to the action consent.

Settlement

Most lawsuits are resolved before getting to trial. The most common way to resolve a claim is to come to a negotiated agreement with the other side. However, if no agreement is reached, the matter may go to trial.

At trial, you will have an opportunity to have your case heard by a judge and perhaps a jury. Typically, all evidence in a trial is given by live witnesses. A trial normally proceeds as follows:

Going to court and having a trial is one of many processes used to resolve disputes between private parties. This article focused on civil litigation, which can be contrasted with a criminal trial (where the Crown is one of the parties and can imprison the defendant). In civil trials, imprisonment is not possible, but monetary damages are usually awarded if the claim is successful.

In BC, the vast majority of court proceedings are started with a notice of civil claim, but in some circumstances, they may also be started by a petition or a requisition. The overarching procedures for starting a proceeding with a notice of civil claim and petition are similar; however, they do have some notable differences.

A proceeding started by a notice of civil claim has the advantage of the discovery process, which is the mechanism whereby parties ask questions of each other under oath and exchange evidence to discover the other side’s version of the facts.

If a settlement is not reached between the parties, they may resort to traditional litigation. Should their claim be $100,00 or less, they can use fast-track litigation.

After reading this article, you can rightly see why deciding whether litigation is the right option for you is best determined with the help of a lawyer and getting the appropriate advice. Give us a call, and we will be pleased to assess the details of your case. Ph: 250-381-4040.